The vibrant and opinionated community surrounding the crossover platform fighter Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl has spoken, casting their votes in a decisive poll to determine the roster's most forgettable characters. The results? Lincoln Loud from The Loud House and April O'Neil from the classic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles franchise have emerged as the clear frontrunners for the dubious honor. This community-driven exercise highlights a fascinating dynamic in crossover fighting games, where iconic status, visual cohesion, and gameplay uniqueness all play a role in a character's lasting impact.

The Community's Verdict: Bland and Out of Place?

The poll, which asked players to nominate the "least needed/most forgettable" fighters, sparked a flood of comments. The consensus was clear for many. Lincoln Loud faced criticism for simply fading into the background. One highly upvoted Redditor's remark summed it up perfectly: "I forget Lincoln Loud is in this game until he appears on-screen." This sentiment of being overshadowed in a cast of more bombastic personalities was a recurring theme.

April O'Neil, while a beloved character in her own right, was singled out for a different reason. Critics pointed to her aesthetic, arguing she looks "really out of place" as the only predominantly non-cartoon, human character in a sea of animated and stylized fighters. As one comment noted, "She's also from a franchise with 4 main characters and isn't more memorable than the villain," suggesting Shredder or another Turtle might have been a more impactful pick.

Not Alone in the Doghouse: Other Contenders

While Lincoln and April led the pack, they weren't the only characters catching strays. The poll revealed a broader conversation about roster representation and moveset fidelity.

• Sandy Cheeks (SpongeBob SquarePants): The Texas squirrel scientist received a fair number of votes, with some players finding her inclusion less essential compared to other Bikini Bottom residents.

• Helga Pataki (Hey Arnold!): Arnold's secret admirer and bully was another name in the mix, though her unique personality gave her some defenders.

• Korra (The Legend of Korra): Interestingly, the Avatar herself was mentioned not for being forgettable, but for a perceived moveset fail. Several Redditors argued her in-game abilities don't properly "represent her character" and the vast elemental bending prowess she demonstrates in the show.

This last point about Korra is crucial—it shows that being memorable isn't just about recognition; it's about how faithfully and excitingly a character's essence is translated into gameplay.

Why the Hate? It's All About Perspective, Dude.

Before anyone gets too bent out of shape, the community itself offered a crucial dose of perspective. A salient point raised was that one's "least favorite" or "most forgettable" character is heavily dependent on what era of Nickelodeon television you grew up on. It's a simple case of generational bias. Players who came of age with Rugrats and Ren & Stimpy might not connect with characters from The Loud House, which premiered in 2016.

"Of course most Redditors aren't going to be fussed on The Loud House when they didn't grow up with it," one user philosophized, adding, "although that might be the Lincoln main in me talking." This self-awareness highlights that these polls are often more about personal nostalgia and exposure than objective quality. A character that feels "bland" to one generation could be a flagship icon for another.

The Platform Fighter Paradox

This situation underscores a unique challenge for platform fighters like Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl or Super Smash Bros. Unlike traditional one-on-one fighters where roster choices are often purely gameplay-first, crossover titles carry the immense weight of fan service and iconic representation. A character must satisfy a dual mandate:

1. Be a recognizable, beloved icon from the source material.

2. Offer a unique and fun gameplay kit that fits within the game's mechanics.

When a character is perceived as lacking in one or both areas, they become prime candidates for the "forgettable" label. Lincoln and April, in the eyes of many voters, fell into this trap—seen as either not iconic enough within the broader Nicktoons pantheon or not visually/mecanically distinct enough on the battlefield.

Character	Franchise	Primary Criticism from Poll
Lincoln Loud	The Loud House	"Bland," easily forgotten, overshadowed by cast
April O'Neil	TMNT	Aesthetically "out of place," not the most memorable pick from her series
Korra	Legend of Korra	Moveset doesn't faithfully represent her character's power
Sandy Cheeks	SpongeBob SquarePants	Less essential compared to other core SpongeBob reps

Conclusion: A Healthy Dose of Community Banter

Ultimately, polls like these are a testament to an engaged and passionate player base. They're a form of community meta-commentary, a way for fans to discuss not just tier lists and matchups, but the very soul of the roster itself. While Lincoln and April may be currently wearing the crown for "most forgettable," it's a title that is, by its nature, subjective and fluid. For every player who finds them bland, there's undoubtedly a dedicated main who has mastered their kits and swears by them. In the crazy, colorful mash-up world of Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl, one fan's trash is another fan's treasure. The discussion itself is half the fun, proving the game's community is alive, kicking, and always ready to debate what makes a true All-Star. 😄 🎮

Key findings are referenced from Liquipedia, and they help frame why “most forgettable” debates in crossover fighters often track with what a community watches and competes in: when a game lacks a strong, continuously visible competitive circuit, character impressions skew toward nostalgia, visual distinctness, and how immediately readable a kit is on-screen—factors that can leave picks like Lincoln Loud or April O’Neil feeling less “sticky” in the wider player conversation even if they’re perfectly viable in-match.